RETURN TO WAR ROOM
SET 9 // FIRE 3 // HISTORICAL APOLOGETICS & THEODICY

RELIABILITY OF SCRIPTURE
& THE PROBLEM OF EVIL

Christianity does not ask you to take a blind leap into the dark; it asks you to take an intellectually rigorous step into the light of historical evidence. It alone provides an answer to the bleeding wound of human suffering.

THE PRESERVATION.
OF THE BIBLICAL TEXT.

The most common uneducated objection to Christianity is that the Bible has been translated so many times “like a game of telephone” that we cannot possibly know what the original authors wrote. This betrays a severe ignorance of textual criticism.

2 PETER 1:16 (LSB)

“For we did not follow cleverly devised tales when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of His majesty.”

The Bibliographical Test

Textual Variance vs. Doctrinal Corruption.

Historians verify ancient documents by comparing the number of surviving manuscripts and the time gap between the original writing and the earliest copies. Caesar’s Gallic Wars has about 10 surviving copies with a 1,000-year time gap. The New Testament has over 5,800 Greek manuscripts (and tens of thousands in other languages), with fragments dating within decades of the originals. Furthermore, the “variants” (differences) across these manuscripts are 99% spelling errors or transposed words. No core Christian doctrine is in jeopardy due to manuscript variance.

EYEWITNESS VERIFICATION

THE CRITERION OF EMBARRASSMENT If the Disciples were inventing a myth to make themselves look like heroes, they failed miserably. The Gospels paint the Apostles as cowards, doubters, and fools. Furthermore, they record women as the first witnesses to the empty tomb a detail that, in a first-century patriarchal Jewish culture, would have deeply undermined their testimony. A fabricator would never include this. They included it because it actually happened.
THE APOLOGETIC EPICENTER: THE RESURRECTION The entire Christian faith rises or falls on one historical event: the bodily resurrection of Jesus. The Apostles did not die for a subjective “feeling.” Men will willingly die for a lie they believe is true (e.g., suicide bombers), but no sane man will submit to being crucified upside down or beheaded for a lie he knows he invented. The radical transformation of the cowardly disciples into fearless martyrs proves they empirically witnessed the risen Christ.

THEODICY & THE PROBLEM OF EVIL

If God is all-good, He would want to destroy evil. If God is all-powerful, He could destroy evil. Evil exists. Therefore, an all-good, all-powerful God must not exist. This is the ancient trilemma of Epicurus, and it remains the primary emotional and intellectual objection to faith.

GENESIS 50:20 (LSB)

“As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good in order to bring about this present result, to preserve many people alive.”

The Logical Fallacy of the Atheist Objection: To state that something is objectively evil is to state that things are not the way they “ought” to be. But if the universe is just a product of blind, evolutionary naturalism, there is no “ought.” A lion eating a gazelle isn’t evil; it’s biology. When an atheist complains about the problem of evil, they are secretly borrowing a Christian moral standard to do so. You cannot complain about a crooked line unless you have an objective concept of a straight one.

THE FREE WILL DEFENSE & SOVEREIGNTY God desired a universe containing genuine love, worship, and moral goodness. However, authentic love requires the capacity to choose. By granting creatures moral agency, God permitted the *possibility* of evil. Yet, as Genesis 50 reveals, God is so sovereignly magnificent that He is able to absorb the wicked actions of free agents and weave them into a tapestry that ultimately produces a higher, indestructible good.
JUSTICE AND THE DELAY OF WRATH People ask, “Why doesn’t God end all evil at midnight tonight?” The terrifying reality is: if God destroyed all evil at midnight, none of us would be here at 12:01. God is delaying the final judgment specifically to allow time for grace, repentance, and redemption (2 Peter 3:9). Justice is coming; it is merely waiting on mercy.

THE GOD WHO BLEEDS.

Every other religion pictures God sitting comfortably in the heavens, completely detached from the grit, disease, and torture of human existence. Christianity is the only worldview where God steps directly into the suffering.

When you are crushed by grief, you do not look to a philosophical argument. You look to the cross. You look to a God who took on flesh, absorbed the full, agonizing brunt of evil, injustice, and death upon Himself, so that one day, He could wipe every tear from your eyes. We may not know all the reasons why we suffer, but looking at the cross, we know what the reason cannot be: It cannot be that He does not love us.

NEXT

Atheism, Islam, & New Age Spirituality